Leaders Without Chests: Minneapolis and the Leadership Crisis We Keep Repeating

What happens when you make leaders without chests?

The question for leaders today is not whether you can think clearly. It is whether you can remain steady when everything around you is trying to pull you toward extremes.

C.S. Lewis wrote something decades ago that feels uncomfortably close to the mark today. In The Abolition of Man, he warned of a future filled with what he called “men without chests.” People with sharp minds and powerful appetites, but without the trained heart that makes virtue possible.

Lewis was not making a political argument. He was making a human one. His concern was that we were slowly losing the moral and emotional center that allows reason and instinct to be ordered toward the good.

Lewis argued that human beings are properly formed when the head, our rational mind, governs the belly, our instincts and desires, through the chest, the heart. The chest is the mediator. It is where emotion is governed, where courage becomes habit, and where values become something more than slogans.

Without that middle element, Lewis said, we are left with cold calculation on one side and raw impulse on the other. Intelligence without virtue. Passion without restraint. Power without wisdom. In other words, men and women without chests.

If you want to understand the modern leadership crisis, you do not need another productivity hack or another clever management trend. You need that diagnosis.

Minneapolis and the Anatomy of a Flashpoint

The tragedy in Minneapolis is a case in point. Tensions rise around enforcement actions or perceived injustice. Communities respond with anger, fear, and grief. Protests ignite. Social media accelerates everything at the speed of outrage. Politicians rush to microphones, point fingers, and egg on their followers to ever more extreme measures. The temperature climbs faster than understanding; the infinite mirror creates a downward spiral. Two avoidable deaths result.

In moments like these, it becomes difficult to tell where accuracy ends and spin begins, where accountability is being pursued, and where outrage is being harvested. The dynamics are not mysterious. They are deeply human.

The head shows up quickly in the form of legal arguments, policy statements, and carefully crafted talking points. The belly shows up even faster in the form of fear, rage, tribal appetite, and the instinct to strike back or double down.

The chest is missing.

The trained heart can hold tension without exploding. You have the intellectual courage to find common ground instead of scoring points. The emotional courage to calm situations, see the humanity in others, and go positive first. The moral courage to do what’s right, especially when your side is pushing the extremes. The steadiness to act rightly rather than react loudly. This is not about one city or one moment. It is about a pattern we keep repeating because character and judgment have lagged behind intensity and outrage.

The Real Shortage Is Not Intelligence

We live in a world overflowing with smart people. Organizations, governments, and communities are full of talent, data, sophisticated tools, and endless analysis. The problem is not a lack of information. It is a lack of formation.

We have leaders with strong heads: strategic competence, technical mastery, and the ability to optimize almost anything. We also have leaders with powerful bellies: ambition, appetite, urgency, the hunger for control or victory, and the fear of losing ground.

We’re lacking leaders with chests, the trained heart that builds bridges, expands trust, and resolves conflict. Without it, systems fracture. Attitudes harden. Trust collapses. People become instruments or enemies rather than human beings.

The word courage comes from cour, the French word for heart. That is not an accident. Courage is not bravado. It is not dominance. It is not adrenaline. Courage is the trained capacity of the heart to see clearly, to trust wisely, and to act rightly, especially when it costs something.

The Invitation in a Divided Age

You do not need more cleverness, louder outrage, or hollow eggheads. You need leaders with chests. Leaders with trained hearts. Leaders who can hold complexity without hatred, who can pursue accountability without dehumanization, and who can build cultures that thrive.

The crisis is not only political, social, and organizational. At its core, it is a crisis of moral and emotional formation. C.S. Lewis saw it coming. The question is whether we will keep producing leaders without chests, or whether we will do the harder, nobler work of building the heart again.

Your company thrives when you build leaders with chests, and developing them is straightforward. The truth is that your leadership capacity is infinitely upgradable. When you exercise the heart, you improve performance, which expands the heart itself, continually elevating your capacity to see clearly, trust deeply, and act decisively.

That is the Heart-Building Loop: the source and the result of disciplined leadership, creating a whole greater than the sum of its parts.

About Author

Chris Kolenda

I work with leaders who want to build unshakeable business endurance.

See author's posts